Don’t tell me I’m too old!
The Reader Digest recently published an article “14 exercises you should modify if you are over 50” https://www.rd.com/health/fitness/exercises-to-modify-over-50/
To say it caused a few raised eyebrows amongst fitness and health professionals would be a understatement. Why did this cause so many people to take to social media to voice their opinions?
Follow the above link and read the article. You can then have an opinion before you read mine.
Ok, here is my take. Warning ANGRY CAPITALS will follow 🙂
This is a broad sweep of an article! As far as I know I don’t have a “Use by” date on the sole of my foot telling me when I should basically give trying to get stronger. To say that when you hit 50 you may want to think about modifying exercises that are vital to everyday function is ridiculous.
There are plenty of very fit and strong 50+ year olds. More to the point there are plenty of people that have THE POTENTIAL to gain muscle and improve cardiovascular health at ANY age (told you there would be angry capitals).
In a time where we are desperately trying to encourage people to stay active and not see age as a barrier, this article is off putting and slightly scare mongering.
Let’s take a look at some of the exercises to modify.
Weighted squats
The article recommends you should only do body weight, so you don’t put strain on your knees. A weighted squat is a progression. Once a client has mastered correct technique only then would you move them on to a weighted squat. Not adding more load when they are capable, is limiting the benefit to the client. It’s a simply principle of overload to increase strength. I would not be doing my job if I didn’t use progression.
It’s also well known weight baring activity is vital for bone strength.
What’s next.
Dead Lift
Another important human movement – the hip hinge. You are going to start to see a pattern here, if the technique is there you should be adding some weight. Who doesn’t want to be able to lift and carry their own bags. Or just be able to lift iron!
Spin Classes
Apparently, the intensity is too hard. Do you hit 50 and lose any sense of knowing your limits. Do class instructors no longer advise you to work to your own level when you hit 50? The most hilarious thing is; that indoor cycling is fine to do in your own home…………in an environment where no help is available on technique or to to advise you to turn the effort up or down. It’s also missing the social element of the class environment which is vital for some people, it keeps them engaged and coming back.
There are many more “Golden nuggets of advice” but I may well damage my laptop from hitting the keys too hard.
At 43, is pressing the keys on a keyboard with slight aggression too much? Should I ask the Readers Digest?
I think The American Physical Therapy Association would probably advise against it!
http://www.apta.org/Media/Letters/2018/9/27/
If an exercise feels good keep doing it and progressing. If it doesn’t get your technique looked at by a professional, they can help you make an informed choice for what is best for you.